Today, I'm going to discuss the issue what what size *you* should expect to be if you lose weight. I personally dabbled into size 18 for about a month, but I have been the following sizes for more than a year in a row: size 16, size 14, size 12, and size 10. I have personal experience of what lifestyle it takes to stay, long-term, in each of these sizes.
Friends, if *you* lose weight how much will *you* ultimately lose? I think that's what everyone wants to know, not how much weight I lost but how much weight *you* will lose.
It depends on you!
Tough love here: The more you cling to or revert back to your
current eating ways, the more your weight will tend to stay the same. Sad, but very true. If you are unsure of whether you cling to or revert back to your eating patterns that got you to an undesirable weight, ask yourself: Is my weight staying the same or am I gaining? If the answer is yes, then you are still using those faulty eating patterns.
If you change your
eating a little bit, your weight will change a little bit. For example, if you eat about 100 to 200 less calories per day for a very long-term basis, your weight should eventually go down about 10 to 20 pounds.
If you have a
significant lifestyle change, you will see a significant weight loss. For example, if you eat 300 to 400 less calories per day for a very long-term basis, your weight should eventually go down about 30 to 40 pounds, which is usually very noticeable.
From my experience, if you are going for a dramatic weight loss, the reality is that you
have to dramatically change your entire lifestyle. If you are trying to lose 50 pounds, you will probably have to eat 500+ calories less per day than you currently eat. For a 60 pound loss, eat 600 less calories per day. For 70 pound loss, eat 700 less calories per day on a consistent long-term basis.
I currently eat about 700 less calories per day than I did at my heaviest weight--resulting in a dramatic weight loss.
Me as an Example of Differing Lifestyle Changes and Corresponding Sizes
Like I said, I've been several sizes, each on a long-term basis. The amount I weighed depended upon my lifestyle at the time.
When I was size 18 for a month or so, I just had to get a little frustrated with
that to turn it into size 16. Size 16 allowed me to eat an entire bag of family-sized candy by myself on Saturdays. I estimate that I ate about 2400 calories per day during those years.
However, getting to size 14 required a significant
lifestyle change of regularly going to the gym and stopping binging. I exercised 6 days a week, and consistently ate about 1800 to 1900 calories per day.
Size 12 was achieved by going to the gym 6 days per week, including heavy weightlifting, and tightening my calories down to 1600 to 1800 calories per day.
But
getting to size 10 required dramatic lifestyle changes. I still go to the gym for at least 5 hours per week, plus at least 100 man push-ups at home once a week. I do not
eat many carbs anymore. I consistently food journal. Every. Single. Day. I average about 1500 to 1700 calories per day, with more lower calorie days per week. I am physically hungry (I'm not talking about carb cravings, here) during certain times of
each day.
Each Size Down Requires Lifestyle Changes
Each size down requires lifestyle changes. When I was size 14, I really couldn't fathom making even more lifestyle changes because I was doing all I could handle at that time.
Yay for You!
If you make the lifestyle change that allows you to go down one size for a long-term basis, you should be very proud of yourself because you had to change to accomplish that. :D
Not So Excited About This...
However, don't get too excited if you barely tolerated a recent weight loss. If you can't tolerate it, it won't be there very long.<<Don't kill the messenger for this, but absorb the truth of it. Down inside, you know this to be true.
Mad Scramble To Eat Much Lower Calories!
Last year, when it really occurred to me that I still ate too many calories, I had to learn how to eat much less each day! A significant calorie reduction per day usually means that a person has to switch out their customary foods that kept them fat and substitute an entirely new menu of food. So, all of a sudden, my pantry didn't have anything on the shelves that I should have been eating! All of those cookies, crackers, pasta, rice, breakfast cereal, salad dressings, etc... no longer applied to my eating. Most things in our family's fridge and freezer were on the "No List" too.
I had to purchase an entirely new set of food for me to eat. Generally, people who eat lower calories per day tend to eat mostly unprocessed food--simply because an orange only has 70 calories when a very small (processed) granola bar has at least 150 calories. Every single calorie adds into the daily calorie amount. As a person gets slimmer, you get fussier about squandering 50 to 100 calories on anything!
Does This Post Make You Feel Grumpy?
It's Only Because I Care.
I had to learn to eat in an entirely different way than I used to eat to get to size 10. If this post makes any of you feel grumpy when you read it, trust me, I would have felt grumpy reading it a few years ago too--because I was personally in denial about how many calories I ate. At a certain point of my life, I honestly felt like eating 1800 calories per day was a small amount--but, in truth, it never was. That was just my delusion talking. I want you to personally succeed, so I tell you the truth.
What do *you* think? Was this helpful to see me as today's lab rat with my own failures and successes for everyone to see? And, of course, anything else you want to say.
Have a Marvelous Day!
:-) Marion
P.S. The struggle has been averted! I was completely back on track yesterday, putting cookies on extremely high shelves, and eating my oranges again. I'm happily back to my normal eating. :D

Marion, this is all so important. So many people just refuse to accept that it has to be a (significant) life style change, and just want it to be a temporary set of denials, that can be 'eased up upon' once they reach goal weight. Ummm, no. It's the bad habits and food choices that got us to being so overweight. It's only by changing those for life, that we can expect to not only lose all of the excess weight, however much it is, but KEEP it off. That's why I always failed at maintenance, after losses in my 40's of 60 lbs. and when I was 59 at over 70 lbs. Because at some point after that, for whatever reasons, I slipped back into the old, bad habits. I have finally accepted that this is for life, and instead of rue'ing that, or feeling deprived, I'm excited by the possibilities of feeling this great (and greater) for the rest of my life. It's an old catch-phrase, but very true; nothing tastes as good as thin feels. :)
ReplyDeletethanks for an excellent post. Tough love is tried and true love. :)
Hi Gwen! As always, I agree with everything you say. Losing a lot of weight is *dramatic* lifestyle change in more ways than just eating. Sometimes, it even means changing types of friends from food enablers (meaning dumping fr-enemies) and choosing more healthy friends.
DeleteAnd people get overly excited about temporary changes. To me, that is a waste of their energy. It is definitely good to lose weight--not matter how long that weight stays lost. However, focusing on the long-term process is how we *keep* weight off--and that is more detail-orientated and much less emotional. More of mathematical calculations of calories each day, really. :D
:-) Marion
Every day is a caloric math day for me, but I stick with some tried and true items, so it's not such a big deal. Good health and better self esteem is SO worth the math. :)
DeleteMarion, this was the PERFECT post for me to write today as I just posted a picture in my blog post today of me in the smallest size jeans I've worn since 1996! I've never worn a size smaller and I definitely want to drop another size or two ... and I need to remember that accomplishing that will require continued dedication and discipline. Is it frustrating to know that this will take a lot of hard work? Perhaps, but not as frustrating as it will feel if I put these jeans on in 2 months and wasn't able to do them up!
ReplyDeleteHi PlumPetals! Well, I immediately went over to your blog to see your new photo. So cute!
DeleteIn my reply to Gwen, I talked about the mathematical calculations of calorie counting being most important. But, we should not forget how super duper awesome(!!!) it is to be in a smaller size! All of us in our smaller sizes are *much* happier with less calories than eating more treats in our former bigger sizes. It is *so* much more fun to shop for clothes or to pick out clothes for a party, or going anywhere really. :D
:-) Marion
It didn't make me feel grumpy. It seems very sensible!
ReplyDeleteHi Connie! That's because you aren't following delusional thoughts--like I used to do! I'm telling you--if you would have told me this back at my fattest in 2006, I would have been mucho grumpy about it.
Delete:-) Marion
At my highest weight of 178 pounds, I should have been wearing size 16 pants every day but I only had one of those. I wore 2X blouses and shirts and I was so happy to get rid of all of those along the way.
ReplyDeleteI am now at a size 10 for pants and a medium in shirts and blouses. I probably won't get smaller than that, but I am finding that even if I'm not losing, my body is changing as I continue to exercise. I like that!
Hi Caron! You have a super cute figure.
DeleteI also like how exercise really sculpts the body. I used to have so much more flab in my lazier 30's than my exercising 40's. I always tell people that the gym is the fountain of youth. :D
Yes, it is also so awesome for me to give my bigger sizes to the thrift store. I used to think that there was so much problems with clothing styles--when the real problem was that I was so lumpy. The smaller sizes really look so much more adorable, and it's fun to get compliments.
:-) Marion
I love this post of yours. You explain it so well as to what someone needs to do in order to lose weight or some more weight if they are standing still.
ReplyDeleteI too have now come to a point where I eat less carbs per day and sugar as well. And it doesn't bother me too a bit. I actually like this way of eating.
I too came to realization that how more slimmer and defined I get, the more fussier I am with regards to my foods. Some don't understand it but I don't really care. I do it for me and not so that they understand.
Hi Marleen! Yes, I've also gotten super fussy with food. I'm not going to eat something I don't really want that has even 100 calories--because as you and I know, regularly doing that will eventually gain a person 10 pounds for that excess 100 calories on a daily basis. I'm guessing by your dramatic weight loss that you also eat about 700 less calories or more per day. Well, that means 700 calories less per day of random food choices. We don't eat nearly as much as we used to, so every calorie really has to mean more.
Delete:-) Marion
Always nice to see you as a lab rat for a change. What you said makes sense. You need to make a significant lifestyle change for every dress size you drop. I never thought of it that way. If I dropped one size I did not make any new changes to drop the next one because what I was doing worked the first time (but no surprise here, I never dropped that next size). As I get smaller so should my calories. It's a good thing I like all those yummy unprocessed foods because it still blows my mind how many calories are in some seemingly healthy items. I've been known to tell Chris I would rather blow 220 calories on a delicious chocolate bar thatn 150 on a dry granola bar. If I'm going to take in calories I might as well enjoy them. Lately I've been reaching for the fresh fruit instead. The healthier I eat the healthier my body wants to eat. I'm no longer getting cravings for junk food and I'm only 2 weeks in.
ReplyDeleteHi Amber! Yes, as I was writing this I was thinking of lab mice each being different sizes and what a scientist would say about that. Too much reading of sciencedaily.com, I guess! :D
DeleteEvery size down is a lifestyle journey. And each next size down is a *brand new* lifestyle journey with more challenging steps. I'm to the point where I rarely think about eating chocolate bars or granola bars because I have such a hard time keeping in my daily calorie amount with either. And both cause me cravings I'd rather avoid. So, like you're saying about fresh fruit, oranges only have 70 calories and taste so good.
You're doing so great, Amber! :D
:-) Marion
Hi Marion, this was a great post..I think it important every change we make is a lifestyle change so there is no risk of going back to a bigger jean size..I also totally agree with weight loss directly depends on the effort we are willing to put...the more effort the more weight loss :)
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely true, Marion!
ReplyDeleteObese people eat way too much food, because a body of that size needs the calories to stay that size.
I would only add that perhaps for the obese person, initially eating a little less and then over time lowering the intake may be less shocking to the system.
Of course, if you can just drop your eating amount to a normal level and sustain it, your weight loss, as you know, will be much faster.
I expect to end at size 8. I could be a size 6 because I'm so short but that is definitely harder to maintain (I ended at size 6 when I lost weight with Weight Watchers ten years ago.)
ReplyDeleteTheoretically, if I gain more muscle mass doing strength training, I could weigh more but still be size 8 or even 6. Time will show..
I got down to a size 8 - and even got a size 6 (which I think must have been mislabeled). I bounced back up to a 10 and have stayed there for almost 2 years now. While I would like to be smaller, like you said I don't know if I have the desire to do what it would take to get back down there *and* maintain it.
ReplyDelete