Wednesday, February 6, 2013

The Lifestyle Change Needed For Weight Loss

This post is not about willpower. I don't have much of it, so I'm pretty sure I'll never write about it.

This post is about my recent conversations and commentary from different people about weight loss and weight management. What is the main difference in the conversation content between those people who are successfully taking or keeping off weight and the strugglers? I will tell you in this post.

I'm pretty sure that I could go through the blogs I regularly read and fairly accurately predict who will successfully lose or maintain a weight loss this year. I also could do fairly accurate predictions at my weight loss group too.

It is *not* about what people are eating that gives it away. Actually, the strugglers often eat very strictly. And I believe them when they say that.

It *is* about the attitude people express regarding losing weight and weight management.

The words "willpower" and "responsibility" are signs of a struggler. The struggler's comment sounds like this, "I need to have exert more willpower toward my weight loss attempts. It is my responsibility to take care of myself. I will force myself to do better this week." They usually talk about the prospect of weight loss in subtly resentful ways. They are going to tolerate calorie restriction.

Another thing I've noticed is that strugglers have a lot of emotional content in their comments about weight management. Their explanations about weight gain or excess pounds nearly always involve how mad, frustrated, sad, stressed...they are about life events.

In contrast, the people who are more successful with weight loss are not talking about "willpower" or "responsibility." They have a more positive tone in their comments. They might talk about sharing their restaurant meal with their best gal friend or their daughter. They might mention that they found a new food that is low-calorie but big on taste. They might describe walking their dog in the Wisconsin winter with new rubber dog boots. Or they talk about a new gym routine or next run they have scheduled. None of these comments involve willpower, responsibility, or any tinge of resentment. It all involves healthy and fun life style choices.

When they gain a little weight, the people who are more successful with their weight easily admit to eating more calories that week than usual. Nobody did that weight gain to them. They focus on their process and their calculations. Comments will usually be about more accurately counting calories, more food journaling, more exercise, drinking more water, getting better sleep, etc... There is very little emotional baggage to their comments.

Weight management is primarily a mind game. I would waste your time to describe how to eat a healthy diet because most of you know that information as well as food dietitians. So that isn't it.

Quite simply, a person has to learn to get happy about eating less calories, day after day, for the rest of their lives. Willpower and responsibility and any other resentment-tinged character trait cannot last that long. You have to learn to really like being a person who consumes less calories.

And because this post has already gotten this long, I'm keeping my specific reasons for why I really like(!!!) being a person who consumes less calories for the next post.

Lastly, I want to say if you are a person whose attitudes fit in the "strugglers" category, every day is a new chance to change. It is never too late for *you* to have a successful weight. :D

What do *you* think? From your experience, does this ring true? And, as usual, say anything you want to add.

Have a lovely day!

:-) Marion

29 comments:

  1. You're quickly becoming one of my faves. I like how candid you are---critical without being contentious.

    I also benefit from your "experience"---you've seen people come and go, and that experience can be a check for me and my attitudes.

    Keep it up Marion

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Chris! Thanks so much for this compliment. (The nerd girl in me also adores how you put candid, critical, and contentious in a single sentence.) I will think about it often today.

    I also really enjoy your viewpoint and reading your blog. You have thoughtful intelligent posts.

    :-) Marion

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Marion - Great post! I think I've been on both sides of this discussion at one time or another. I know too many people in my real world (not internet, not saying you aren't real, just that we haven't touched hands in person) Anyway...I know too many people in my real world that think of dieting as food deprivation. Which immediately for them gives it a negative connotation. Which means ultimately that it won't last, and then the verbal excuse machine kicks in.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Marc! I spent most of my adult life(!) on the other end of this discussion! So I certainly understand the struggling aspect. There is some sort of cycle of negative connotation and verbal excuses, as you suggest.

      :-) Marion

      Delete
  4. This is so true. I think the key to being successful in losing weight and keeping it off is to find a new lifestyle that works for you. It's not about going "on" and "off" a plan. You have to make peace with food and realize that you won't be able to eat the way you did before again. And you have to feel good about that decision. I think finding ways to deal with emotions, etc. is another important part.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Andrea! Well, you are such a great example of feeling good about your eating.

      The emotions: Yes, a huge topic by itself. Lately, I'm finding myself doing better when I leave them out of the equation. Do the proper actions to move myself forward that day (even if it doesn't feel comfortable), and worry about how I feel about it later. But usually, this ends up making me happy.

      :-) Marion

      Delete
  5. This really struck a chord with me. Even though I try to be positive, and I have developed many new habits that I enjoy, I am still harboring a lot of resentment and emotion. I think I am a struggler who is trying to move toward being a succeeder.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Connie! I definitely think you are moving to where you want to be.

      :-) Marion

      Delete
  6. Awwwwww.... you and your posts just make my day Marion!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Scribbles! Thanks! I appreciate your new spirit added into the blogging world. :D

      :-) Marion

      Delete
  7. As I was reading this I was thinking - which one am I? Which one am I? I think I'm somewhere in the middle if this were on a spectrum - and perhaps even more towards the successful side than the struggler. I was definitely a struggler. Then, when my mindset and attitude changed, I started to become move along that spectrum and become more successful. I still struggle, but I am determined to be successful :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Dr. PlumPetals! When I used the term "strugglers" in this post, I just meant weight-wise. We all struggle, but our attitude surrounding it really matters. You are really happy about where you're at, and where you're headed.

      :-) Marion

      Delete
  8. Hi! I'm new to your blog, and really impressed! Looking forward to more from you; I know you'll help me on my path to better health!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Gwen! Thanks! It is always great to get a new blogging friend.

      :-) Marion

      Delete
  9. I've been in both camps, but now I'm more in the latter group! :) In my opinion, if you have to exert a lot of willpower to stick to your diet, there is something wrong with it. The diet is probably too strict and doesn't fit well into that person's lifestyle.

    I love my daily dose of white chocolate. :-)

    I've started practicing the tree pose...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Satu! I think that "willpower" has an undertone of resentment. And that attitude will inevitably wane, regardless of whether the diet is good or not.

      However, people should try to make diets as happy as possible. I am currently nibbling on mini chocolate chips, as I do on most days. You are having your white chocolate. It's pretty hard to feel sorry for one's self with a daily dose of chocolate--even if it is a small one.

      Yay tree pose! I always feel so smart when I do it, because I know how much it tightens the muscles around my knees and ankles. An added bonus is that it looks like an art form. (And I can't help but whisper that it tones up the butt. :D)

      :-) Marion

      Delete
  10. Eye-opening and I believe your statements to be accurate. You gave me some things to think about because I am not applying the same attitude towards my weight loss journey as I do the other things in my life that I am successful at. Never really thought of it this way.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Amber! Yes, really imagine something you are very good at that you need absolutely no willpower for--because you just *want* to do it. Than apply that exact attitude to your eating. That kind of successful attitude works wonders!

      :-) Marion

      Delete
  11. I both disagree and agree. I think there is a tipping point. When I started out it was about willpower, food-wise and workout-wise. I exerted so much of it in that first month or so. Once the results followed I was able to change the mindset. It was no longer about having the will to lose weight or be at the gym, but desire to see what I could do next. It took time to get to that point though.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Chris! Yes, I understand what you are saying, but I remain true to everything written in this post. Willpower is a heavy ball and chain to lug around. Yes, a person can do it for a while, but not for very long to make very long-term changes.

      Your magic, Chris, stems from you absolutely loving your fitness. I personally know how (not!) hard it is for you to convince yourself to work out. You are freakin' happy about it, just as I'm saying in this post. And because of that, I really believe that your fitness and weight changes will last.

      :-) Marion

      Delete
  12. Hey, I Nominated you for the Liebster award! It`s sort of like a chain letter type of award, pretty cool and kinda fun!

    http://wisdomcouragepower.blogspot.ca/2013/02/the-liebster-award.html

    Stay Awesome!
    Chris

    ReplyDelete
  13. I'm definitely at the 'all talk' and complete losing weight-fail at the end of the spectrum - as you know!

    I think the moment I become more zen about it will be the moment it all falls into place. (I hope!) Though I know that it will continue to involve making one right choice after another.

    Deb

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Deb! I don't know if I'm close to "zen" at all. I'm a very antzy person, who fidgets and moves all day long. And I listen to rock music and Pitbull when I do yoga by myself.

      I think it is more about seeing fitness and weight loss as gaining better opportunities from them. Straightening out one's body triggers needed changes in other areas of life, which align with the body's change. All of my changes were needed (even though I didn't even know they were needed until the changes happened) and the change has been very happy for me.

      :-) Marion

      Delete
  14. Willpower is vastly over-rated for sure, Marion! That's why I always suggest concrete behaviors like keeping trigger foods out of the house, to support the illusive will-power.

    Picking up and putting down some concrete doesn't hurt either :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Dr. J! Yes, I love my rules and concrete behaviors because they make life so much easier!

      Yes, will-power is illusive. And I *don't* think very highly about the highly regarded will-power books on the market right now, because those readers are not going to find the long-term answers they are seeking.

      :-) Marion

      Delete
  15. Great post Marion. For me, I just eat the exact same way I did while losing the weight. I found an eating plan I can do forever. I wouldn't say this works for everyone. I have issues for sure. I'm afraid to eat processed carbs and sugar, so I don't. Don't know how healthy an attitude that is about food!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Great post. I agree. I hear so many people say they don't have the "willpower" to lose weight. I had so many health issues, willpower was never even a consideration. I was going to lose the weight no matter what! Instead of "willpower" I changed that to determination.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Marion, this is my first visit to your blog. It won't be my last. Your post has given me some to think about as I squarely fit into the 'struggler' role. Wow is all I can say for now. Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Making healthy eating and exercising a lifestyle is very important and it does take a lot of effort...especially if you have been making bad health choices..I think initially for very long I was a struggler, I would look at every healthy food choice negatively..thats why the weight would never come off...slowly I changed my thinking now I find it easier to stick to healthy options..(actually I don't even have to think twice..) ever since this change the weight has come off and it is easier to maintain too :)

    ReplyDelete